Does the defensive style still have a future?

By Thierry Verviers
Active and Passionate Table Tennis Player and Coach for over 40 years

Almost 35 years ago, when I was a young inexperienced coach, the strongest player in my club was a Vietnamese player who played with long pips. Very often, I had heard him and many other players say that the defensive style had no future because table tennis was now a sport way too fast and attackers were advantaged in terms of equipment. Strangely, every time this player, Tran Van was in trouble during a competition, he started to play his defensive style. On several occasions, I saw him win tournament finals that way. What a paradox coming from a player who said that the defensive style had no future. So the question is the following.

Why would anyone want to play a defensive style today?

First, let’s establish what it means to play defensive.

The modern defender is a player who uses mainly defensive strokes far from the table, spin variations and surprise attacks as soon as an opportunity arises. It is rather reactive style, and adapts to the game of the opponent. He plays smart and makes sure that the offensive actions of his opponent are as ineffective as possible for example, by causing him to take too many risks.

Now why do some people decide to be a defensive player?

There are many reasons, but here are some of them.

  • It’s one of the most fun and satisfying styles to play. There are many long and beautiful rallies when one is a defender.
  • Some players want to slow down the game. Why? To have time to think. They find the attacking game too fast for them. In this way they add some reaction time.
  • Some players think this is the most effective style of table tennis. So, in agreement with their coach, they decide to play defensive.

And that’s where the question comes up.

Is the defensive style an effective one?

First, let’s say that the defensive style is much less popular than the offensive style. It is not uncommon to see clubs in North America who have no defenders amongst their players. And yet, according to January 2017 ITTF data, among the top 50 players in the world, 6% of men were defenders and 16% of women were too. Proportionately speaking, given the small number of club-trained defensive players, it may be that this style is actually the most effective! Think about it

To make this style popular, we would simply need a defending world champion. It almost happened at the 2003 World Championship in Paris where, against all odds, Joo See-Hyuk, a Korean defender, reached the final, which he lost 2-4.

Is it so easy to play defensive?

Technically speaking, the technical gesture of the chop defense is more difficult to master than the topspin. At the trajectory level, the topspin ball falls shorter on the table, while the chop continues in a straight line often for too long, even beyond the table. It is also necessary to be able to read well the spins of the opponent and adapt its strokes accordingly. It takes a good hand and also a good ball touch.

It also requires excellent footwork, which automatically leads to the requirement for excellent physical condition.

In addition, you have to be an excellent attacker too, because at a certain level, waiting for the opponent’s mistake is no longer enough to win the game.

All that makes the defensive play difficult to master and I would say that it is more difficult than playing an offensive style.

Why do we find a lot of defensive players in the veteran categories?

Another striking thing is the high number of defensive players found in veteran categories.

One may wonder why many players decide to become advocates when they get older?

The answers are rather logical:

  • The older we become, the more our physical condition diminishes. The offensive style becomes more and more difficult to play. Defensive play gives them a chance.
  • The reaction time also decreases with age. The player tries to adapt and play defensive, so that he gains reaction time.

That’s why I adopted a defensive style since I’m 57 years old.

On the other hand, this style requires larger movements, so it will not be easy to play for an older person. This is why we see many older defensive players playing closer to the table with short or long pips, for example.

Should we show defensive play to our young players?

The answer is yes and no.

Having more defensive players in a club would help develop stronger offensive players. On the other hand, it is not any young person who can become a defender. It takes some special features that very few young people have:

  • They must be very good defensively, but just as much offensively.
  • They must enjoy moving a lot and working very hard physically.
  • They must be prepared to train very hard both physically and mentally.
  • They must be very interested in the different spins, trajectories and adaptive tactics.
  • They must be convinced that they will be more likely to have better results as a defender.
  • They must have patience; it takes more time to become a great defender.
  • They must have the support of their coach and family.

What kind of equipment does it use to play defensive effectively?

Most defensive players use defensive woods that are not necessarily defensive in speed. Defender blades are often larger than attacking blades so that it has a larger sweet spot and thus promotes control of the ball. The larger blade will also allow a better balance on the racket with the lighter rubber used often with a sponge of only 0.5 or 1 mm.

Blades suggestions

Capture d_écran 2018-08-22 à 20.35.42Butterfly Gionis Defense Blade ST

Capture d_écran 2018-08-22 à 20.35.30TSP Super Defensive Blade

Capture d_écran 2018-08-22 à 20.35.12Victas Koji Matsushita Defensive blade

Other Defensive blade

Most defensive players use long pips and some use short pips, especially on the backhand side. But who says pips, does not necessarily say defensive. Some long pips are made for offensive blocks and most short pips are made for speed.

Long Pips Suggestions

Capture d_écran 2018-08-22 à 20.43.34

TSP Curl P1R Soft Rubber (Long Pips)

Capture d_écran 2018-08-22 à 20.43.21

Palio CK531A Rubber (Long Pips)

Capture d_écran 2018-08-22 à 20.43.07

andro Rasant Chaos Rubber (Long Pips)

Other Long Pips Suggestions

It is important to mention that most modern defenders can twiddle, or switch sides from backhand to forehand. They can therefore use the long pips on either side.

In the past some players like the Christian Martin from France, used smooth rubber on both forehand and backhand. Others used anti-spins instead of pips. But let’s say it’s more and more rare.

What can be concluded from all this?

The defensive style although less popular is perhaps equally effective.

The defensive style may be more demanding than the attacking style.

Make sure your young athletes have the right characteristics before suggesting the defensive style.

It may allow older players to extend their career like mine for example 😉

But actually, everyone should at least try it … to see how much fun it is to play this style.

Some videos of famous defenders …

Men

Women

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s